Often teachers ask me about topic generation. I also know nothing sends terror down the spine of a teacher, then 20 or 25 children who are complaining, “I don’t have anything to write about.” Obviously, I am exaggerating! Or a child who has written about the same frog for 26 days in a row. It is not a matter of assigning a topic or not a matter of saying, “Don’t assign topics!” The solution is in what is happening in the discussion before writing. When I enter a classroom as a writing consultant, I want all children to write, as do all the teachers, I have ever met. So how does this happen? Students need ideas not assignments for topics.
As we look forward to seeing our students tomorrow, I think about the writing workshops across the country. I want students to write about their significant people. I want children to write about what matters to them. I know if we help our students through questioning to think about traditions that matter, they will write about them. Who did they see over break? What happens every year?
I could write about…
After dinner, Santa comes to our house. He is real. …
OR
Everyone in our family knows that my mom does not mail presents. We all open presents at my mom and dad’s house on Christmas morning. …
OR
My dad cooks once a year. Christmas morning breakfast …
As I think about the ‘who’ and a tradition, it helps trigger a memory and a tradition I could write about. This is what we need to do with our students to prevent a list of “What I got for Christmas!”
I wrote about this topic previously here: Person: Think of person that matters to you
and here: writing about special people
and here: Gooney Bird book teaches about personal narrative
Filed under: Debra Renner Smith, small moments, writing consultant | Tagged: Debra Renner Smith, literacy coaching, Lucy Calkins, mini-lesson, small moments, writing, Writing Workshop | Leave a Comment »